|
|
Sahib
Mustaqim Bleher Assesses the Surah Like It
Challenge
"And if you are in doubt concerning
that which We have sent down (i.e. the Qur'ān) to Our slave
(Muhammad Peace be upon him ), then produce a Sūrah (chapter) of the
like thereof and call your witnesses (supporters and helpers)
besides Allāh, if you are truthful." (Qur'an 2:23)
Recently, there has been some
commotion concerning the challenge of the Qur'an to produce a Surah Like
It. After having his attention drawn to an Internet site that
claimed to have met the challenge, Sahib Mustaqim Bleher decided to
write to the site owners. Below is a copy of the e-mail sent to the
site owners. We are currently waiting for a reply and will keep you
informed of any new developments.
Dear folks,
Firstly, I agree that there should be no
stifling of debate. Secondly, the challenge of the Qur'an to try and
produce a Surah like one of its own is meaningful only if it does
not preclude people from trying. However, they should be more honest
in their presentation. The original site completely omits the
background information you present on your Pipex site, and by merely
listing so-called "Surahs" does give a false impression. It also has
no room whatsoever for informed discussion. It may, therefore, given
the evangelical content of the "Surahs" be intended to inflame. If
it is to be a proper challenge, it should afford room for people's
comments, and it should also present original Surahs to which the
fabrications claim a likeness, so as to enable outsiders to judge
the merit of the claim. Being an Arabic speaker myself, I can tell
you that the invented Surahs come out very poorly in rhythm, rhyme,
and grammar, not to talk about the idiosyncracies of meaning. The
English translation, of course, only makes the meaning available. If
they were honest, the authors should subject their "Surahs" and the
orignals on which they modelled them to an independent textual
analysis by a reputable linguistic institution and make those
findings available. It is the dishonesty in publishing the material
without background and opportunity to respond, which makes Muslims
object to the existing of the original "Surah like it" site. You may
publish this letter if you wish.
Yours sincerely,
[Please note we have
received no reply from the site owners. The email was sent to them
on 14/Dec/2000]
Further
Links |
Islamic Awareness
: An insight into the 'surah like it challenge' and responses to
some of the failed challenges.
Notice: We do not necessarily endorse
the information provided by any external site. These links are
provided as a service for the community.
Back To Top
|
|